Beyond the Manual: Governance and School Leadership
Contact Us
  • Home
  • The Governance Corner
  • Learning to Learn Differently
  • Support for Schools

The Governance Corner

A forum for discussing issues in Independent School governance in the third decade of the 21st Century

Read all Posts

Decline your vote? Are you kidding me?!

6/10/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
I'm not usually turned off by any aspect of discussions of politics or political strategy, but this week I have been disgusted. Don't get me wrong, it is not the usual mudslinging among politicians that has me down, it is an article in today's Ottawa Citizen that gives voters their primer on how to "decline" their ballots. This is the epitome of the dilettante commentator telling people to discard their right of citizenship in order to express an absolutely useless non-opinion on the fate of their province (in this case Ontario) for the next four years. I tweeted my dismay with this article and was told to basically "lighten up" by a national writer for Macleans. Have our pundits become so cynical that they no longer can understand the real value of the franchise? Have voting and elections become a vegas-like betting game in which pollsters and commentators make predictions and then take the voting public for granted like gamblers setting the odds?

This week the Globe and Mail editorial Board instructed voters to elect a minority government. Have they never studied parliamentary elections? Don't they understand that it's not like hedging your bets, it's making a deliberate choice for the future?

On Thursday, the voters of Ontario have the opportunity (far too rare) to make clear policy choices and direct a potential government as to their preferences for the next half a decade. There are drastic differences between the front runners and interesting policy proposals among the also rans. So, if I am an Ontario voter, why would I choose either not to vote - a cop out - or to make a pretentious show of arriving at the poll and dismissing all of the alternatives? The day after the election, both these choices are moot.

To be honest, after decades of calling Toronto my home, I now live in North Vancouver. The decisions made by the Ontario electorate are theirs and theirs alone. I have a mother, children and grandchildren who will be affected by the outcome of this election, but I trust their judgement to consider the issues, the parties, and the candidates, and to vote for their best option.

No party is perfect, no choice is without its pluses and minuses. But to give up your right to give some direction (and no, a spoiled or declined ballot is not a direction - it is a conceit) is the greatest insult to our parents and grandparents who fought for that democratic right.

On the 70th anniversary of D-Day, do we take our democratic freedoms so lightly that we want to trade them for a snarky tweet?

If you have the power to vote, use your intellect and your best judgement, and make a real choice. 

0 Comments

Dumbing down democracy

6/2/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
It is hard to pick up a paper or look online and read a commentary that doesn't base its argument upon a misunderstanding of parliamentary democracy. There are three basic misconceptions that warp our view of how the system is supposed to work.
The first was evident this week with all of the banter about "coalition" governments. This piece of nonsense harkens back to the "crisis" of 2008/9 when the airways were filled with claims that votes of confidence, and a potential change in government due to determining who could actually command a majority of support in the House of Commons was going against the democratic will of the people!

Part of this problem lies with our first past the post system the allows a party with a plurality of the vote to win a majority of seats. The "mandate" for a "strong, stable majority government" is often provided against the wishes of two-thirds of the voting public. In a minority situation, the myth is stretched to maintain that a few extra seats is an indication of popular support and, if the combined parties receiving the majority of both the votes and the seats choose to work together, that this somehow thwarts the wishes of the electorate.

We have heard these cries this week as it gradually becomes clear that there might be no clear "winner" in the upcoming Ontario provincial election. No matter what happens June 12th, Kathleen Wynne has the right to go to the legislature, as Premier, and to determine whether or not she has  the support of the majority to govern. This is not a shell game, this is parliamentary democracy.

The second issue is the emergence of the myth of the "leader". In a caucus and cabinet system, it is ludicrous to base voting decisions on who might be the ideal Prime Minister. The fact is, the best PMs in Canada have been characterized as effective collaborators and team leaders who surrounded themselves by highly capable cabinet Ministers who were given their heads of steam to run their departments. Look at the great non-Prime Ministers of Canada - Clifford Sifton, C. D. Howe, Walter Gordon, Paul Martin, Jim Flaherty - to name a few. Parliament was never intended to be a one-person show. As long as the media keep playing the game of reporting who Canadians think would make the "best" Prime Minister, we are going to be stuck in this watered down version of the American Presidential system.

Finally, as citizens, we have more and more been fragmented into wedge constituencies. Our concerns have narrowed to what is best for us as individuals in the short term and a vision of what might be best for society in the longer view has disappeared from public discourse. The most discouraging aspect of this has been the replacement of the concept of "citizen" by the rallying cry of "taxpayer". The underlying assumption is that the more that you pay in taxes, they more say you should have in how the country is governed. This is not just a product of the noblesse oblige of the 1% but is equally at home in the "Ford Nation" who look on many members of society - the unemployed, homeless, seniors, students, veterans, temporary foreign workers - as not pulling their weight.

The depths to which we have fallen was never more clear than in an interview a while back between Evan Solomon and Chris Alexander on The House. The discussion was around regions paying the federal government back for monies expended on emergency relief. The logistics and timing of payback were debated but at no time did the basic issue of our duty to support our fellow citizens in time of need come up for consideration. If an ice storm hit Montreal, or a flood swamped Calgary, or a tsunami crashed into Haida Gwaii, the government saw itself as a banker lending money that would be paid back rather than a conduit through which the rest of Canada could chip in to support their neighbours.

This is no way to run any political entity. These three misconceptions do a disservice to our parliamentary democratic heritage as Canadians.

0 Comments

    Author

    Dr. Jim Christopher
    has been working with Boards and Heads on Governance issues for the past 15 years. He is a former Superintendent of Schools, ED of the Canadian Association of Independent Schools and Canadian Educational Standards Institute and is the author of a number of books and articles of education and governance. His latest book, Beyond the Manual: A Realist's Guide to Independent School Governance is available on iTunes or at https://www.smashwords.com/books/view/388729

    View my profile on LinkedIn
    21stC Podcast

    Archives

    March 2022
    April 2020
    July 2019
    March 2019
    September 2018
    July 2018
    February 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    April 2016
    September 2015
    August 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly